Monday, November 16, 2020

On the acknowledgement of messages

 Recently, I've been hit with a virus - I'm in a twenty-person text thread which was initiated, for purposes unknown, by a some kind of spam genius organization. Frankly, I love it - I'm proud of the spammers: they've created a perpetual spam machine that has no clear end in sight. Every day or so, sometimes multiple times a day, an exchange like this occurs:

A frustrated member of our self-created prison lashes out, demanding that we all stop texting, and then a helpful good Samaritan replies, explaining that texts sent to the group do, in fact, get sent to the entire group. Of course, the ultimate irony is that by chastening the first texter, goodie two-shoes is the prime mover of the next exchange, ad nauseam, ad infinitum.

Hats off to the spammers, this is top notch spam!

Saturday, April 25, 2020

Spotify Podcasts

I was recently listening to the Invest Like the Best interview with Daniel Elk, the CEO of Spotify, and was stuck by the dissonance between the theoretical articulation of the product vision and direction and my lived experience with the product, specifically as it relates to podcasts.

While Daniel coherently walked through the Clayton Christensen "job to be done" framework (also popular with the instagram founders in an earlier episode), I was shocked about how poorly the Spotify product team seems to have adopted this lesson in their product development strategy.

Specifically, while there's an overlap between the times I'm hiring spotify to find and curate music and when I'm hiring spotify to find and curate podcasts, after that initial decision, it feels like the team retrofitted the existing spotify app and user experience without critically thinking through how users actually want to interact with a podcast-specific experience.

In particular, I was shocked to see that they tried to smash podcasts directly into the existing Spotify app rather than having a podcast-oriented application geared specifically towards podcast users. As an episodic medium with repeat consumption and curation, podcasts are just very different than traditional music. Additionally, once I've decided to listen to a podcast, the likelihood of me wanting to listen to music is extremely low - podcast-specific search, prioritization and discovery is much worse when mixed up with musical mediums (https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/Podcasts-Split-out-podcasts-into-separate-app/idi-p/4938692).

This is the approach Facebook has taken with Messenger, and Gmail took with Inbox; as a user, I get a tailored experience without being distracted but content unrelated to my general user-intent.

As a final aside, while I understand the complexity of the b2b partnership side, as a consumer, if spotify is trying to move into podcasts, the lack of audible / deep integration with books-on-tape feels like another way to control the user experience.

Sunday, February 23, 2020

Data / Model-driven writing tools

For ~5 years, I've continuously returned to this blog post:

I think that there's something so subtly powerful about being able to take data / logic and surround it with rhetoric and prose. Most tools separate these out between Word / Excel / Powerpoint, but I think that successes of things like dashboarding tools and other interesting kinds of data-driven visualization tools make me really excited about the kinds of tools we should be focused on building as technologists.

Saturday, February 15, 2020

Incident Response

Part 1 and Part 2 and are here – main takeaways below, but recommend reading the raw papers for more detail. Overall, I think that we do a pretty good job of this, but especially as we move towards more Operational Responsibilty, Baseline, and PRX working closely together, worth reviewing for some ideas of where things fail in a distributed incident response environment. Some of my notes below:

  • It was really cool to see the rigor with which they analyzed the response rather than the incident itself – there are a lot of papers about “bad bugs” but less about “collective multi-engineer debugging.”
  • Organizational complexity often mirrors system complexity (Conway’s Law) conflating incident response.
  • How important decentralized agency / autonomy is in incident response – “plans / actions” are often poorly decomped and require high-trust operators to go off script.
  • Reminds me a lot of patterns in immunology with antibodies / tcells / general sympathetic nervous response, as well as trauma triage principles in emergency medicine.
  • Willingness to achieve “immune response” and bring in expertise rather that fearing the repercussions of over-escalating.

Thematically, I think that the most important takeaway for me is that preventative design is not enough: while it’s really important to design our software and try to prevent catastrophic failure, it’s probably equally valuable to design our human / organizational response systems in a way that quickly resolves these catastrophes.

Saturday, January 4, 2020

My favorite books from 2019

This year didn't have much of a theme - it started as a Japanese variant of my Russian 2017 and Chinese 2018, but the theme just didn't stick. In another wandering year I read more fiction that I have in awhile, and started retracing my steps a few times with fun intersections with other books I've been thinking about for the past few years.

1. The Making of the Atomic Bomb
So far, there's always been one book I read that just stuck in my head. This year, probably because of some deep moral questions about my own work, Rhodes' classic was the book that stuck. He crafted a beautiful three-phase narrative from scientific discovery, to technological development, to political and military application in a way that felt authentic and honest. More than anything, Rhodes painted a fully three-dimensional portrait of the larger-than-life men who participated in the last great arms race of our species, and his empathy and respect for their contributions combined with a lightweight narrative of caution and technological skepticism made the 900 page history book fly by like a fantasy novel.

2. The Revolt of The Public and the Crisis of Authority in the New Millennium
This is the hipster-pick - only ~300 other people read this book in 2019, and I probably know 10 of them. That said, it's an essential read for people trying to synthesize what's happening in the world of politics and democracy. Importantly, it's a cautionary tale of government overpromising and underdelivering even as populations ask government to assume even more responsibility for problems across society. Paradoxically, the increased accountability provided by a decentralized media actually is presented as a negative, making it too easy to throw stones and progressively harder to provide any positive narrative for societal change. The only solution is a massive reduction in the exception of government, combined with a huge increase in actual results, but such a solution is untenable given the cyclical nature of democratic politics; to actually acknowledge these limitations would be a politically untenable choice.

3. Matterhorn
This semi-autobiographical novel was an incredible story that combined great writing with incisive political analysis and a strong anti-war message that's only more important to reflect on going into the 19th year of our own contemporary wars in the Middle East. As a narrative device, the author's choice to flip perspectives between soldiers in a firefight and commanders trying to reason through things back at base was a chilling reminder that abstraction and distance breeds the kind of intellectually pure cruelty that Scott warns against in his famous critique of High Modernism, Seeing Like a State. Fighting a mathematically pure war is the best way to guarantee maximal suffering on all sides. The choice to weave these two different perspectives together, and the impressive literary ability to do so in a way that didn't feel forced is the true genius of this book.

4. Mistborn
This year, I read two Brandon Sanderson trilogies, and man does this guy know how to craft a story! Though I loved the Stormlight Archive, Mistborn took the cake; the purity of the magic and the foreshadowing was great, and while I didn't love the second book, the first and third books were some of the most fun fantasy I read this year.

5. The Beginning of Infinity: Explanations That Transform the World
This book is weird, refreshingly so. It's an epistemological book, with the basic central theme that the only morally pure pursuit is to obtain progressively more knowledge in a way that's fundamentally unbounded. To Deutsch, we will never know everything, and that's part of the joy of being human! I don't think that Deutsch is always right, but he's a unique mind: the way he thinks about the world and humanity's place in it is a refreshing breath of optimistic epistemic fresh air, and this book succeeded in changing the way I think, the highest compliment for any book!



Sunday, October 20, 2019

Integrity and Athletics

For years, I've been opposed to athletic recruiting at elite academic institutions; it seems obvious to me that athletic accomplishment is but one factor that should be considered individually and in the process of building out a well-rounded student body. In particular, the prioritization of athletics over artistic, musical, and scientific excellence during the university recruiting process has always struck me as a quirk of history.

This quirk of history recently made the national news when investigators discovered that certain coaches were taking bribes from wealthy parents in order to push students through the recruiting process.

What confuses me isn't that this happened, but that university leadership didn't take this opportunity to modernize the system. This would have been the perfect catalyst to take a national stand and act with courage and intellectual fortitude in order to attempt to switch the Ivy League from Division I to Division III, or to remove itself from the NCAA entirely. Instead, university leaders took the path of least resistance, instituting minor and insignificant policy changes which do nothing to address the root cause of the problem: allowing college admissions to be warped by the need to recruit athlete-students rather than student-athletes.


Thursday, October 3, 2019

Cyberwar and the Economic Battlespace

Note that cyberwar for the purposes of this essay is meant to refer to mechanisms of conflict that are fundamentally oriented around gaining access to siloed intellectual property, rather than the conventional definition which is more expansive and includes political manipulation and the targeting of traditional military target with cyber-weaponry, sometimes resulting in the destruction of physical property.

As an increasing amount of aggregate global value comes from intangible, non-traditional assets such as human capital and intellectual property, and as the relative value of raw materials and commodities decreases, modern nation states face a new competitive landscape. In particular, while historical conflict was zero sum as a result of finite amounts of geographic space and the fixed resources contained within a given border, modern conflict also involves attempts to develop, destroy or redistribute these more abstract resources.

These abstract resources have a number of attributes which make them challenging to think about without updating our fundamental assumptions which underpin many classical theories of conflict. This essay focuses on the conflict over intellectual property, but I believe that conflict over human capital is equally fascinating given trends towards specialization and a much wider distribution of human capital across the population.

Intellectual property has long been a challenging type of capital to protect; the asymmetry between the high cost of developing new technology and the relatively low cost of deploying existing technology makes it a tempting target for competitors. If achievable, acquiring access to technology without bearing the development costs is a strong strategy.

Further, unlike in a traditional conflict, transferring technology between combatants does not harm either entity on an absolute basis: technology transfer eliminates the profit that can be extracted by producers of the technology, but the intrinsic value is often increased, and always conserved.

In these terms, belligerents in cyberwar could be considered as fundamentally moral from the perspective of a finite game: by stealing proprietary property and releasing it publicly, access to that technology would become broader, increasing the amount of value in the world.

At the limit, as the share of "abstract value" created by access to new technology increased relative to the share of "raw value" defined by access to physical materials, it would be theoretically possible to completely redistribute value across the population, resulting in a non-violent Marxist equilibrium ("from each according to his ability to each according to his need").

However, from a capitalist's perspective, this equilibrium would also signify the end of progress. If the only way to create new value is through developing new technology, and the pervasive theft of intellectual property decimates the return on capital that a private entity can expect to obtain from the development of new technology, markets will no longer be able to function to fund and develop new technology, and this equilibrium will represent a pyrrhic victory. Without the ability to fund innovation in present by relying on proceeds from the future, technology would stagnate and one of our most unique assets as a species (the ability to shape our own evolution) would be destroyed.

As such, cyberwar represents a fundamental battle between socialist and capitalist values: if you believe that technology development would occur at the same rate without market incentives, it is fundamentally moral to redistribute it as soon as its developed. If, on the other hand, you take the other side, and especially you believe in non-linear compounding growth of knowledge and technology, this equilibration is likely the single greatest threat to progress for our species, and you should probably take up arms in this quintessentially modern form of battle.

The good news, though, is that once we start fighting over abstract goods, with abstract weapons, in abstract spaces, the only true harm that is possible in the present is relative, which means that even the price of conflict is fundamentally abstract and requires discounting into future.

And how fun is that!